It sounds like you understand the reasons people on both sides of the Arizona law have for their positions, and you recognize that some of their behaviors are stupid. However, I don’t see any hint that you understand the reasons people who would like to continue drilling in the gulf have for their position. I think any argument that people are being stupid should address the stupider reasons they have (or behaviors they exhibit), rather than simply saying their position itself is stupid.
I speak as a champion of stupidity. I firmly believe that if we do not allow people to be stupid legally, we do them a great disservice by prohibiting them from learning through the school of hard knocks. Furthermore, those that violate the prohibition are motivated to hide their reasons and behaviors, which makes fixing any problems they cause that much more difficult.